Essence Gel Liner in 01 Midnight in Paris
Wet N Wild Gel Liner in 886
E.L.F Cream Liner in Black
Essence Wet N Wild E.L.F
All three are very intense black. However Essence is the most creamy while Wet N' Wild has a drier formula.
WATER SMUDGE TEST
Took some water, rubbed it across all three, and excuse my horrible swatching skills but no one budged.
MAKEUP REMOVER TEST
Took a contain swab dipped in makeup remover, ran it once over all three. Essence faded, Wet N wild barely moved and with one more swipe E.L.F would have disappeared.
If you are looking for an awesome liner all around, then get the Essence Liner. It is creamy so it goes on SOOOO smooth. It doesn't smudge and lasts all day. Plus they have a very nice color selection for those divas wanting to experiment with colored gel liners :)
If you are looking for a liner that won't move for days, go ahead get the Wet N Wild Liner. That little sucker stays on even after you remove it. Although a little drier in texture, it is very easy to apply.
Side Note: Thank u all for the congratulation's, it really meant a lot, and as far as putting up pictures, im so sorry but I can't. Mi familia decided that they needed to be in every picture so when I asked if I could share them online, they all shied away :) But no worries, someday I will put up pics:)